Why do we defend a phone, a drink or a group as if it were our team? Groups made at random, “us against them” and the pleasure of what we have built.
Level A2 · Grammar focus: Possessive pronouns and whose · ⏱️ 5 min
⚽ My Team, My Phone
Do you have a favourite football team? Some people love their team so much that they get angry if you say something bad about it. It is “our” team, not “their” team. Now think about a phone, a sport shoe or a soft drink. 📞 Many people also defend their favourite brand in the same way!
This is strange, because a brand is only a company. Why do we feel like it is ours? Psychologists have some answers. In this text, we look at three of them. Ready?
🎨 The Group Made by Chance
A famous experiment shows how quickly groups are born. Scientists took some boys and put them in two groups. 🔬 They told them that the groups were about their favourite painting. But in fact, the groups were made by chance, with a coin! 🪙
After that, the boys had to give points to other boys. And what did they do? They gave more points to the boys in their own group, even if they did not know them. This is called “in-group favouritism”. It shows that our brain likes to divide people into “us” and “them” very fast. 🧠
👕 Winning Together
Another experiment looked at students at a university. 🏫 After their football team won a match, more students wore the shirts and caps of the university. After a defeat, fewer students wore them. Why?
Psychologists call it “basking in reflected glory”. When our team wins, we feel that we also win. So we say “we won” and not “they won”. When it loses, we say “they lost”. It is a way to feel good about ourselves. Brands use the same trick: they want you to wear their name.
👀 The More You See, The More You Like
There is also the “mere exposure effect”. When we see something many times, we start to like it, even if we don’t know why. A new song, a face or a logo becomes nicer when we see it again and again. 🎵
That is why advertisements are everywhere: on the street, on the bus, on your phone. 📞 You don’t need to love the product. You only need to see it often. After a few weeks, it feels like a friend. 🤝 The product seems to be yours.
🛠️ The Things We Make Ourselves
Whose furniture is the most special to you? Many people say: the furniture that they built themselves. Researchers found that people value a thing more when they make it, even if the result is not very good. 🔬 This is called the “IKEA effect”.
The same idea works for brands. 💡 If a brand asks you to make something, for example a personal design, a name or a profile, you feel that it is yours. It becomes “mine”, not only “theirs”, and it is harder to leave it.
💡 Did You Know?
A rival makes love stronger. When another brand is the “enemy”, the fans of the first brand are more united. They say: “That one is theirs, but this one is ours.” Brands know this. Sometimes they make funny jokes about their rival.
But there is some good news. You can enjoy your favourite brand and still think with your own head. A simple question helps: “Whose interest is this? Is it mine, or is it the company’s?” If the answer is “mine”, it’s a good choice.
📚 Glossary
| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| team | a group that plays together |
| favourite | liked best |
| brand | the name of a product or company |
| soft drink | a cold drink without alcohol |
| company | a business |
| psychologist | a person who studies the mind |
| experiment | a test to learn something |
| chance | luck, without a plan |
| coin | a round piece of metal money |
| point | a unit in a game |
| favouritism | giving better treatment to one group |
| divide | to separate into parts |
| student | a person who studies |
| shirt | clothes for the top of the body |
| defeat | a loss |
| basking | enjoying warmth or credit |
| glory | great honour |
| exposure | being shown something |
| logo | a symbol of a company |
| advertisement | a message to sell a product |
| furniture | tables, chairs, beds |
| build | to make something by putting parts together |
| value | to think something is important |
| result | what happens at the end |
| design | a plan for how something looks |
| profile | a personal page online |
| rival | a person or company that competes |
| united | together |
| fan | a person who loves a team or a brand |
| interest | something good for you |
| mine | belonging to me |
✅ True or False
Write T (true) or F (false).
- ___ In the experiment, boys were put in groups by their painting choices.
- ___ The boys gave more points to their own group.
- ___ After a defeat, more students wore the university shirts.
- ___ ‘Basking in reflected glory’ means we feel good when our team wins.
- ___ The mere exposure effect means that we like things we see often.
- ___ We value things less when we make them ourselves.
- ___ A rival brand can make fans more united.
- ___ A brand is more than a company, according to the text.
- ___ We can enjoy a brand and still think for ourselves.
- ___ The text is only about football.
✍️ Grammar Practice: Possessive pronouns and whose
Complete with mine, yours, his, hers, ours, theirs or whose.
- It is our team. It is ___ team.
- That shirt is mine. That shirt is ___.
- ___ furniture is the most special to you?
- This is her phone. This phone is ___.
- They built the shelf. The shelf is ___.
- That brand is yours. This brand is ___. (me)
- ___ scarf is this? It is Tom’s.
- This is his logo. The logo is ___.
- We made it. It is ___.
- Is this bag yours or ___? (Anna)
🔑 Answers
True or False
- False – The groups were made by chance with a coin.
- True – This is in-group favouritism.
- False – After a defeat, fewer students wore them.
- True – We say ‘we won’.
- True – Advertisements are everywhere.
- False – We value them more: the IKEA effect.
- True – They say ‘this one is ours’.
- False – A brand is only a company.
- True – A simple question helps.
- False – It is about brands, teams and groups.
Grammar Practice
- ours (our team: ours)
- mine
- Whose
- hers
- theirs
- mine
- Whose
- his
- ours
- hers
Why do we defend a phone, a drink or a group as if it were our team? Groups made at random, “us against them” and the pleasure of what we have built.
Level B1 · Grammar focus: Both, either, neither, all and none · ⏱️ 5 min
⚽ My Team, My Brand
Many people defend their football team as if it were part of their family. 👨👩👧 Strangely, the same people may be equally loyal to a phone, a pair of trainers or a soft drink. 📞 Both the fan and the customer say “we” when they talk about the group, even though neither of them owns a share of it.
Why does this happen? Psychologists use a theory called “social identity”: part of how we see ourselves comes from the groups that we belong to. 💡 When a brand becomes one of those groups, an attack on it can feel like an attack on us.
🎨 Groups Made by Chance
A famous experiment from the 1970s shows how fast groups can form. Researchers told a group of boys that they were being divided into two teams, according to their preference for one of two painters. 🔬 In reality, all the boys were assigned by chance.
Even so, they gave more points to the boys in their own team than to the boys in the other team. Neither group had a real reason to compete, and none of the boys knew each other. The result suggests that our brain divides the world into “us” and “them” almost automatically. 🧠
👕 Basking in Reflected Glory
A study of university students found that, after their football team won, many more students wore clothes with the university name. 🏫 After a defeat, far fewer did. Psychologists call this “basking in reflected glory”: we share the success of our group, but we distance ourselves from its failures.
Notice the language: after a victory, people say “we won”, but after a defeat, they say “they lost”. Brands exploit this by giving fans a way to wear the group on their body, through logos, colours and slogans.
👀 The Mere Exposure Effect
Another mechanism is the mere exposure effect. All of us tend to like things more simply because we have seen them more often. Neither the quality of a song nor the beauty of a logo is necessary; repetition is often enough. 🎵
This is one reason why companies pay for advertising in so many places. Either we notice the message consciously, or we don’t, but in both cases the familiarity grows. After a while, the brand feels like an old friend. 🤝
🛠️ The IKEA Effect
People also value things more when they have helped to create them. In experiments, volunteers who built simple items by themselves were willing to pay more for them than for identical items that were already finished. This is sometimes called the “IKEA effect”.
Companies know it. If a brand invites you to design a product, choose a name or build a profile, you invest effort, and the effort makes the result feel like yours. All of this makes leaving the brand harder, because you would be leaving a piece of yourself.
💡 The Power of a Rival
Rivalry makes group feelings stronger. When there is another team or brand to compare with, the members of both groups feel closer to each other. Some companies encourage this with jokes about their competitors, and fans either laugh or become angry.
None of this means that loving a brand is wrong. But it is useful to ask yourself whose interests are being served. If you can answer that the choice is good for you, and not only for the group, you can enjoy it without losing your own judgement.
📚 Glossary
| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| defend | to protect |
| loyal | faithful |
| trainers | shoes for sport |
| customer | a person who buys something |
| share | a part of a company |
| theory | an idea that explains something |
| social identity | how we see ourselves through groups |
| belong | to be a member of |
| divide | to separate into parts |
| preference | liking one thing more |
| assign | to give a place or role |
| compete | to try to win |
| automatically | without thinking |
| defeat | a loss |
| distance | to keep away |
| exploit | to use for advantage |
| mere | nothing more than |
| exposure | being shown something |
| familiarity | knowing something well |
| consciously | knowing what you do |
| volunteer | a person who offers to help |
| identical | exactly the same |
| invest | to put in time or money |
| effort | hard work |
| rivalry | competition between two groups |
| competitor | a person or company that competes |
| encourage | to give confidence |
| serve | to be useful to |
| judgement | an opinion |
| slogan | a short advertising phrase |
| success | a good result |
✅ True or False
Write T (true) or F (false).
- ___ Fans and customers may both say ‘we’ about a group.
- ___ Social identity means that we see ourselves partly through our groups.
- ___ In the experiment, the boys were divided according to real differences.
- ___ Neither group had a real reason to compete.
- ___ After a defeat, more students wore university clothes.
- ___ The mere exposure effect says that repetition can make us like things.
- ___ People value self-made things less than finished ones.
- ___ Rivalry makes group feelings weaker.
- ___ The text says that loving a brand is wrong.
- ___ Companies sometimes make jokes about competitors.
✍️ Grammar Practice: Both, either, neither, all and none
Complete with both, either, neither, all or none.
- ___ the fan and the customer say ‘we’.
- ___ of the boys knew each other.
- ___ group had a real reason to compete. (not one of two)
- ___ of us like things we see often. (everyone)
- You can have ___ the red one or the blue one. (one of two)
- ___ the song nor the logo is necessary.
- I like ___ teams; I can’t choose. (the two)
- ___ of the students wore the shirt after the defeat. (not one)
- ___ brand is perfect, so ask questions. (no, of two)
- ___ the boys gave more points to their own team. (every one)
🔑 Answers
True or False
- True – Neither owns a share.
- True – A brand can become one of them.
- False – They were assigned by chance.
- True – Even so, they favoured their own.
- False – Far fewer did.
- True – Neither quality nor beauty is necessary.
- False – They value them more: the IKEA effect.
- False – It makes them stronger.
- False – It says that we should ask whose interests are served.
- True – Fans may laugh or become angry.
Grammar Practice
- Both
- None
- Neither
- All
- either
- Neither
- both
- None
- Neither
- All
Why do we defend a phone, a drink or a group as if it were our team? Groups made at random, “us against them” and the pleasure of what we have built.
Level B2 · Grammar focus: Collective nouns and subject-verb agreement · ⏱️ 5 min
⚽ When a Company Becomes a Tribe
A football team is a collective noun that people tend to treat as a single emotional entity: the team is playing well, the crowd is singing, the fans are furious. What is remarkable is that the same loyalty is increasingly directed at commercial brands. A group of customers can defend a phone, a trainer or a soft drink with a vehemence that was once reserved for sport or ideology. 📞
The explanation lies largely in social identity theory, according to which part of our self-concept derives from the groups to which we belong. 💡 When a brand becomes one of those groups, criticism of it is processed as a personal affront.
🎨 The Minimal Group Paradigm
In a series of studies in the 1970s, researchers divided schoolboys into two groups on a trivial pretext, ostensibly their preference for one of two painters, while in fact assigning them at random. 🔬 The staff were astonished to discover that the boys systematically favoured members of their own group in the distribution of points, even though the group was anonymous and offered no personal benefit.
This finding, known as the minimal group paradigm, suggests that the mere categorisation of people into “us” and “them” is sufficient to produce favouritism. If a coin toss can create a tribe, a logo and a slogan certainly can. 🪙
👕 Basking in Reflected Glory
Another classic study found that the number of students wearing university apparel rose after a victory by the football team and fell after a defeat. 🏫 The team, it seemed, was a mirror in which the students saw themselves. Psychologists call the phenomenon basking in reflected glory.
The language reveals the mechanism: after a win, supporters say “we won”, but after a loss, “they lost”. The audience was quick to identify with success and slow to share failure. Brands exploit this by offering a wearable symbol of membership, so that the crowd can display its allegiance.
👀 Familiarity Breeds Affection
The mere exposure effect, documented by researchers since the 1960s, holds that repeated contact with a stimulus increases liking for it, even without conscious recognition. The family of advertisements that surrounds us daily, on streets, buses and screens, relies on this tendency. 👨👩👧
The implication is that preference can be manufactured by frequency alone. A jury might struggle to decide whether it prefers one logo to another, but its members will almost always favour the one they have seen most often.
🛠️ Labour Breeds Love
Experiments by behavioural economists indicate that people place greater value on objects that they have helped to create, a result sometimes called the IKEA effect. A team of volunteers asked to assemble simple items was willing to pay more for its own products than for identical finished ones.
Companies exploit this by inviting customers to customise, name or design their purchases. The staff of a well-run brand know that effort invested translates into attachment, and that attachment makes it more difficult to leave.
💡 The Rival as an Ally
Rivalry strengthens group cohesion. When a competing team or brand is present, each group becomes more united, and its members polarise against the other side. The police of a stadium know this well, but so do marketing departments: a good rival is the best advertisement a brand can have. 👮
None of this implies that attachment to a brand is irrational or harmful. It does suggest that we benefit from asking whose interests a choice serves. The committee that governs our own judgement is better off when it is aware of the pressures on it.
📚 Glossary
| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| collective noun | a word for a group, like team |
| entity | a thing that exists |
| furious | very angry |
| vehemence | strong feeling |
| reserve | to keep for a purpose |
| ideology | a system of beliefs |
| self-concept | the way you see yourself |
| derive | to come from |
| affront | an insult |
| trivial | not important |
| pretext | a false reason |
| ostensibly | seemingly |
| systematically | in a regular way |
| anonymous | without a name |
| paradigm | a model or pattern |
| categorisation | putting into groups |
| apparel | clothes |
| allegiance | loyalty to a group |
| stimulus | something that causes a reaction |
| manufacture | to make or create |
| frequency | how often something happens |
| customise | to change to your own taste |
| attachment | a strong feeling of connection |
| cohesion | being united |
| polarise | to divide into two opposite sides |
| irrational | not based on reason |
| benefit | to gain something good |
| committee | a group that decides things |
| aware | knowing about something |
| jury | a group that judges |
| supporter | a person who supports a team |
✅ True or False
Write T (true) or F (false).
- ___ A collective noun like ‘team’ is usually treated as one entity in the text.
- ___ The minimal group paradigm used real differences between groups.
- ___ The boys favoured their own group even though it offered no personal benefit.
- ___ Students wore university clothes less after a victory.
- ___ The mere exposure effect needs conscious recognition.
- ___ A jury will usually favour the logo it has seen most often.
- ___ People value things they built less than finished ones.
- ___ A rival can strengthen group cohesion.
- ___ The text says attachment to brands is irrational and harmful.
- ___ Asking whose interests a choice serves is recommended.
✍️ Grammar Practice: Collective nouns and subject-verb agreement
Choose the correct verb form (British English: singular for a unit, plural for members).
- The team ___ (is / are) playing well tonight. (as a unit)
- The crowd ___ (is / are) singing. (as a unit)
- The staff ___ (was / were) astonished to discover the result. (as individuals)
- The family ___ (is / are) having dinner at different times. (as individuals)
- The audience ___ (was / were) quick to identify with success.
- The committee ___ (has / have) made its decision. (unit)
- The police ___ (is / are) at the stadium.
- A group of customers ___ (defend / defends) the brand.
- The jury ___ (is / are) arguing among themselves.
- The government ___ (is / are) planning a new law. (unit)
🔑 Answers
True or False
- True – People treat it as one emotional unit.
- False – The groups were assigned at random.
- True – The group was anonymous.
- False – More students wore them after a victory.
- False – It works even without conscious recognition.
- True – Frequency creates preference.
- False – They value them more.
- True – Each group becomes more united.
- False – It does not imply that.
- True – It helps our own judgement.
Grammar Practice
- is
- is
- were
- are
- was / were
- has
- are
- defends
- are
- is